Friday 22 June 2007

Stadiums

Now, being a Liverpool fan at the moment there is a lot of talk about the new stadium plans. The new American owners have scrapped the old plans for the New Anfield and have re-designed the stadium to emphasize the Kop as well as allowing room for expansion at a later date. The plans are to be released soon but it has made me look at other stadia being developed and built around the world. My question is about the seemingly generic appearance of many stadia around the world. They are all becoming the same 'bowl' shape and are moving away from the old 'atmospheric' feel, something which i feel is integral to the whole football experience.


Original Plans for the new Anfield, above.


and an alternative design emphasizing the Kop and keeping an 'old fashioned' look.

The search for these new stadia led me to many different examples:

Nottingham Forest's proposed new stadium, bearing in mind they are in league one do they expect to fill it?


Similar story in Brighton...

...and Doncaster...

...and Luton...

...and Milton Keynes...

...and Southend, with a wierd little growth off the side of it. Bizare!


Of course the Americans have always been into their bowled stadia and this is just the latest edition, the new Dallas Cowboys Stadium - http://stadium.dallascowboys.com/



For good measure though...

...Oldham Athletic, that's more like it!

Do people agree that the designs are generic? or are they a mark of the modern era of architectural designing?

1 comment:

ksw said...

I completely agree that all the new stadium designs are similar. Of course architects have to consider function, so maybe this is the best shape for a stadium, but what about originality? Pushing the boundries?

Stadiums are huge, expensive structures that will change and dominate the area's skyline and will be around for a long time. Shouldn't they be trying to make a bold statement that makes the area unique and gives it a personality that ties it to whataver sport or club is hosts? The old wembley was such an iconic building for England- architects should try to create landmarks that are a source of local pride.

Look at selfridges in Birmingam- a huge building that's completely changed the look of a traditional department store. When will someone do that with stadiums?